[I'm still working on a Cosmocking but urrrgh it's terrible trying to make something interesting out of Cosmo. In the meantime, here's a not-at-all-disturbing story from my richly wayward teenage years. TRIGGER WARNING for emotional abuse and survival sex.]
When I was 16, I ran away from home. My mother was abusive, I'd just brought home bad grades (I'd started college at 15 and that was a mistake) and she'd exploded and kept exploding. It was mostly emotional abuse, with only occasional and mild hitting, but as bad as emotional abuse can get, it got.
She'd wake me up in the middle of the night to scream at me. She'd scream at me for literally (as in, I checked the clock) hours on end and I would say nothing but "yes, you're right" and "I'm sorry" the whole time, just standing there quivering and waiting for it to be over. She'd scream at me for doing anything I wanted--you don't deserve to sit around reading a book!--and scream at me for doing anything she wanted--you think just because you cooked some shitty dinner that makes it okay? I wasn't allowed to close my door and I wasn't allowed to leave the house. I didn't know when it was going to end, I had long since resorted to self-mutilation to deal with the stress, and I was afraid my life would be a living hell for months or years if I didn't get out.
So I got out. I was, despite being a Child Prodigy™, a very young 16 and I didn't have a plan, or any realistic idea of what it would be like to be a runaway. I just stuffed some clothes in a backpack and (after waiting for my mother to leave the house) walked out the front door. I didn't know where I was going. I just wanted to get far enough away she couldn't find me.
The first night, I slept in a park. Or tried to sleep. I think I got about two hours, curled up in the little concrete alcove outside a locked-up park bathroom, trying to hide. I was painfully aware of how much I had to hide from--the weather, criminals, cops, even animals. I didn't eat anything the next day. I was not good at being homeless.
The next night, I met up with a guy I knew. He was a lot older than me, sort of a friend, sort of a weirdo, still lived with his parents, but he had a private entrance to his basement. He used to screen porn films for me and some other underage girls. Never did anything to us, just watched them with us, and we thought he was so cool for being over 18 and allowed to buy porn.
Let's be fair here; he didn't offer me food and lodging for sex, not in so many words. I "seduced" him. I got food and lodging out of it. He didn't hurt me but he did make it clear that I'd have to leave if I stopped sleeping with him. For banging him every night and most mornings, I got about four days of a safe bed to sleep in and the food in his fridge.
It was vanilla sex, with condoms, not painful or demanding, and frankly it was even kind of enjoyable on a surface level--I had orgasms and everything. But it was also... detached. I had no illusion that I was doing it because I was horny. I was doing it because it was the only way I could think of to stay alive without my mother. The guy knew this, but I think he also thought of himself as my rescuer, and me the grateful damsel happy to give herself to her rescuer.
My parents knew this guy, so before long the cops came by his place and dragged me home. (He didn't get in any legal trouble for any of this. Although I did find out much later that my dad threatened to kill him. High five, Dad.) Shit with my mom got even worse after that and I ended up leaving home for several months, but that's another story and one that fortunately doesn't involve survival sex.
This is the kind of thing that I'm reluctant to talk about, because I worry that it hurts my credibility as a sex-positive person and especially as a BDSM-positive person. It fits too neatly into a narrative of "she's fucked up and that's why she does freaky shit." I don't think that's true--I was freaky before this, I know freaky people who weren't abused and abused people who aren't freaky--and I also don't think I should care so long as my freakiness isn't hurting me now.
But I'm wary of the "damaged goods" pity-smear, of being reduced to my traumas, and sometimes it silences me. I don't want to make this blog into a narrative of "ex-child-prostitute/emotional abuse survivor/sexual assault survivor has promiscuous and painful sex!" Every part of that is technically true but it's not my story. It's ridiculous just how little it's my story.
I want to share it, though, because it's a complicated story. I wasn't quite the stereotypical "runaway forced into prostitution"--I knew the guy, it was only one guy, I wasn't forced into anything, I was free to leave, and most importantly, I would have (in fact did) fought tooth and nail against someone "rescuing" me in any way that either put me back with my mother or dumped me out on the street. But I certainly wasn't the happy hooker making a free choice to do sex work as a career. (I don't mean to deny their existence, just to say that obviously I wasn't one.) It wasn't forced sex nor was it chosen sex--it was survival sex.
Sometimes I feel like I haven't grown up; I feel like I've finally run away and gotten away with it. I may have a job and an apartment and be back in school, but it doesn't make me feel like an adult. It makes me feel like a runaway who finally made it away.

That's intense. Thanks for sharing. If it helps any, I grew up with mild emotional abuse that did not directly lead to freakiness, but I still ultimately discovered that I am a freak (bisexual, polyamorous, kinky) which I also believe to be unrelated to the aforementioned emotional abuse.
ReplyDeleteJust to back you up. And for what it's worth (even though I shouldn't speak for others, so take this with a grain of salt) - my girlfriend grew up with relatively little emotional abuse (and no other kind afaik) and she, too, has a high sex drive, is bisexual, poly, and kinky, like me.
The interesting thing for me (this might fall under that "Chinese curse" definition of interesting) is that I know someone who has a story of survival sex - the dorms closed down for Xmas and wouldn't let students stay, so what was there to do but call a "friend" who wanted to be more and pretend, in exchange for not having to sleep in a park during a NY state winter.
ReplyDeleteThe person who told me the story is a guy, the "friend" was a girl he wasn't attracted to, and while he's not emotionally touchy-feely and has a TON of abusive stuff that happened to him all throughout his life, it stands out to him as something that was particularly fucked up. Because he felt he didn't have a choice. Because there were no provisions for students without anywhere to go. Because he feels guilty for lying to her about what was going on. Because he wasn't attracted to her at all and can't pretend that he wasn't exchanging sex for a roof.
Complicated!
The system where dorms close for "vacations" is a really messed-up, privilege-assuming thing. I know a lot of people who dread vacations because they have to go back to an abusive family or because they have nowhere at all to go.
ReplyDeleteAnd I think about how much it would suck--and how incredibly illegal it would be--if my landlord just up and "closed" my apartment.
I realize it would raise costs (although not that much), but closing down dorms just assumes all the students have nice warm homes waiting to take them in for the holidays.
Holly - you are totally right there. I always find the attitude many universities take toward dorms and dorm life to be condescending and even taking advantage of students. Most dorms (at least in my experience) are not even particularly cheap - yet they enforce silly rules, some don't take complaints of theft/vandalism/harassment seriously and they kick you out one day after your last exam. That makes it tough even for relatively privileged people like me, whose single parent works and I work and have no vehicle to get out of town. Landlords can't get away with those kind of shenanigans so I don't understand why colleges can.
ReplyDelete>>Sometimes I feel like I haven't grown up; I feel like I've finally run away and gotten away with it.
ReplyDelete>> I may have a job and an apartment and be back in school, but it doesn't make me feel like an adult.
>> It makes me feel like a runaway who finally made it away.
This is *not* an attempt to snark you, but....
What do you think it will take for you to "feel like an adult"? You are clearly in control of your own life (as much as anyone is), you are accepting responsibility for who you are and what you do (and even what you feel), and you are working out several positive missions (your budding medical career; this blog).
Many of us (56-year-old self included) sorta never feel we have "grown up", but I *do* think I'm an adult. I'm curious why you don't.
I don't think I'll ever feel like an adult. I'm closer to 30 than 20 and I'm pretty sure I'll always feel like a kid who, due to some sort of administrative error, has been allowed to drive a car and rent an apartment.
ReplyDeleteProbably the only think that would make me feel like an adult is if I had kids of my own, but since I don't plan to do that...
Maybe if I bought a house. But I'm pretty sure this would just make me feel like this: http://xkcd.com/905/
(Also relevant: http://xkcd.com/616/)
I find it interesting (maybe ironic is the word) that some of the people with the potential to be the best parents don't want kids.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing this story. It gave me insight into something that never even crossed my mind. I think it's a tragedy that there was nowhere else for you to go. Not that we want children running away all the time. But sometimes it just gets to be too much to handle and it would have been nice if you had a safer place to go.
I also have a lot of respect for the fact that you didn't blame the guy for doing what he did. IMO he took advantage, but faced with a similar situation a lot of guys might have done the same. You were able to see the situation from both points of view and just tell it like it is.
Lastly, I know you'll get a lot of supportive comments like this one. But, why does it take a story like this for people (myself included) to show support. Why can't we just support our fellow human beings?
I was so sure one of those 2 links would be this!
ReplyDeletehttp://xkcd.com/150/
<3
flightless
I feel like a pain in the ass for doing this, but your bit about not wanting to be reduced to your traumas really struck a chord with me. I was sexually abused by a lot of different people when I was twelve, secondary school was basically a place for rape culture to breed (only one teacher sent a boy out because he called a girl a slut in class) and I had to leave a job because the guy harassing me was much less expendable. At this moment I get off on pretty boys getting tortured and crying (in fiction of course) as well as some other things of that ilk and I drive myself insane with "what if all that hadn't happened? did it cause my sexual tastes? would I be vanilla if my introduction to sex wasn't rape?"
ReplyDeleteI guess my longwinded point is... how do you silence the thought of feeling like damaged goods?
IMO he took advantage, but faced with a similar situation a lot of guys might have done the same.
ReplyDeleteNo. NO. I still see his behavior as reprehensible. It was taking advantage of someone vulnerable, and I don't see how "oh, other guys might do it" makes that any better.
Also, realize this may not have been what you meant, Holly, but uh, just because an orgasm is involved doesn't mean it's PLEASANT.
--Rogan
The people who will reduce this post to "she's into freaky shit because of survival sex" would probably dismiss what you have to say anyway. Their loss.
ReplyDeleteI hope that I'm appreciating this post for what it is: a nuanced account of one person's experience that beautifully illustrates a few of the many shades of grey in human and sexual interactions.
Thank you for sharing.
"No. NO. I still see his behavior as reprehensible. It was taking advantage of someone vulnerable, and I don't see how "oh, other guys might do it" makes that any better."
ReplyDeleteI didn't say his behavior was irreprehensible and I also didn't say that the fact other guys might have done the same makes it any better. I actually made no judgement on his behavior except for the fact that I mentioned that he took advantage and that was obvious anyway. I really just commented on her matter of fact way of telling the story, and ability to look at the situation from his point of view. I wouldn't have thought any less of Holly if she would have demonized the guy and called him all sorts of names but I just respected the fact that she didn't.
Whoa there. I don't at all not-judge the guy. I judge the shit out of him. He had the chance to offer a kid in trouble real help--to tell me "that's ridiculous, you can stay with me as a friend" at the least, to hook me up with the city's resources for homeless and abused youth if he really wanted to do me some good--and instead he decided to get his dick wet because he was a lonely nerd who was into little girls.
ReplyDeleteI can't paint him as a total monster because I knew him too well for that, I saw some of his good sides, but he's also not an ordinary guy doing something we all might. Not at all. I'd like to think that fucking runaway girls actually isn't a common human foible.
Think less of me if you want, but no, I'm not totally at peace with him and how he treated me.
Holly: You are awesome for sharing this. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteEmmeline: wow. We apparently have overlapping kinks and overlapping trauma issues. For me, there is probably a link between them as well. (Such as: topping is a great way for me not to freeze up and panic during sex. So probably it has something to do with my control issues.) But if my subconscious is doing its processing via kink? I do not harm real people, nor do I inflict my sexuality on anyone without their enthusiastic consent. Who cares what I would've been like in an alternative universe? I figure that as long as you're not hurtful to the people around you, there is no wrong way to be.
Anon 11:37: Exactly. Lots of what really revs our motors comes from subconscious hobgoblins. So long as the actual issues have been resolved, who the hell cares where the kinks come from.
ReplyDeleteHolly: It's the "made it clear he'd kick you out if you stopped sleeping with him" that raises the ick level. As a straight dude, I'll be honest; if a friend I fancied made a pass at me, I wouldn't look that gift horse in the mouth. Making it a requirement makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up.
First off, thank you Holly for sharing something so personal and, I'm sure, scary to share. So sorry you had to go through so much crap, and so impressed that you made it through to become such a strong and inspiring person.
ReplyDeleteSecondly, just for the record, for anyone who looks at this story and the other brave people in the comments sharing their past hurts and trying to make something of it: I happen to have lucked out massively in the parents and overall childhood department. My parents were neither physically nor emotionally abusive, and in fact were and are wonderfully supportive without being smothering. They are not perfect, given that they are human, but they are some of the best I've ever heard of. I was also lucky enough to be born after my family became very financially secure, and make it through childhood without any notable traumas. And yet I am a (happy and proud) pervert - bi, poly, kinky, masochist, submissive, unapologetic boot fetishist, you name it. So nope, it's not inevitably a reflection of past abuse. Plenty of us abuse-free lucky bastards are kinky as all get out.
And finally, to agree with Anon 11:37 and needsaname: some of us are kinky and it has nothing to do with past abuse (either because we were lucky enough not to experience abuse, or because we experienced abuse but it has no connection with our kinks), and some of us are kinky in ways that are partially influenced by past abuse and that's okay. Or at least it can be okay. If we have found a healthy, happy, functional way to deal with our past and have fun, consensual sex into the bargain, why not? Certainly not the worst of possible coping strategies!
Oh dear Goddess, and I thought my dad was bad when HE got angry. *hugs Holly* I suddenly feel fortunate that I was never awakened in the middle of the night to be yelled at. That doesn't even make sense damnit father why must I love and hate you so much.
ReplyDelete"Sometimes I feel like I haven't grown up; I feel like I've finally run away and gotten away with it. I may have a job and an apartment and be back in school, but it doesn't make me feel like an adult. It makes me feel like a runaway who finally made it away."
This is exactly how I feel. As bizarre and unrealistic as it is, I keep expecting to be dragged home and have to endure a 2-hour screaming match with dad. I still don't mention my religion or my bisexuality to non-Pagans I know IRL, because part of me is terrified that word will get back to dad and he will Do Something To Me. Not sure what, but it will definitely be Something Horrible, or so my paranoia insists.
I'm not totally at peace with him and how he treated me.
ReplyDeleteMiranda: I think that's entirely understandable and perfectly all right.
instead he decided to get his dick wet because he was a lonely nerd who was into little girls.
Rogan: Wow, that describes our rapist too! They must've been on the same mailing list.
Man judging from the comments a lot of people don't know if they're adults yet or not. Kinda same here, maybe it's a modern development?
ReplyDeleteIt'd be great if we had a similar to b.c. era initiation rituals and if you passed then you could no longer doubt yourself if you are a adult or not - you passed the ritual and that's it.
Hah. No, then you'd think "I didn't pass that on my own merit, I got lucky!"
ReplyDeleteI had a Bat Mitzvah but that really didn't help at all.
ReplyDeleteI guess part of it, for me, is that all the adults I knew as a kid were either married or living with their parents, so for me Being An Adult is tied up with Living With Someone. I currently live alone with the dog.
ReplyDeleteThere's a bit in his biography (written by his wife, a comedian and psychologist) where Billy Connolly says that he worries every day that someone's going to come up to him, pat him on the back and say "well, you've had fun, but now it's back to reality", and take him back to the dockyard he was stuck working in as a young man.
ReplyDeleteHe was in his 60s at the time. Even after decades of international success as a comedian and travel presenter, he felt that same thing. I don't know whether that's more sad or more reassuring, but it's always stuck with me.
I don't think there are any adults in the world. Everyone is faking it.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteMy mom used to yell at me for hours too! It was for being sexual, or doing things that she suspected were sexual, or being suspected of doing things that she suspected were sexual. I learned not to respond at all to what she was saying; it made it last longer. So, I wouldn't talk to her. I learned to sit very still. I learned not to change my breathing patterns. Any kind of response would just make her think she was right about whatever she was saying.
ReplyDelete"He was in his 60s at the time. Even after decades of international success as a comedian and travel presenter, he felt that same thing. I don't know whether that's more sad or more reassuring, but it's always stuck with me."
ReplyDeleteI like this story. I think fear that you'll be "taken back" is a common thing--I've had my current group of friends for two years and I still sometimes snap back into the feelings of loneliness I had as a teen!
The guy took advantage, no question. That's despicable.
ReplyDeleteA true friend, or even just a gentleman, would have said "You don't have to do that. Stay as long as you need".
But...
Would that have been any less despicable, or would it just have made him a NiceGuyTM?
Would that have been any less despicable, or would it just have made him a NiceGuyTM?
ReplyDeleteUh. If someone offers me crash space, it's a plain nice thing to do. It's the EXPECTATION of sexual repayment that's despicable.
Seriously, I don't even understand what this comment is supposed to MEAN.
--Rogan
A NiceGuy is someone who offers you crash space hoping you'll sleep with him.
ReplyDeleteA genuinely nice guy is someone who offers you crash space no-strings-attached.
And both of those are still less despicable than what he did.
I feel I may as well mention that the genuinely nice guy may also be sufficiently attracted to you to hope you'll sleep with them, but in no way feel that their offering of crashspace should have any bearing on this at all and be cool with the fact that you don't want to.
ReplyDeleteI can't help but be reminded of a scene in Per Petterson's To Siberia in which the heroine begs shelter for the night and incidentally uses the occasion to get rid of her virginity ("It gave me no pleasure but he didn't say "No thanks," and then that was done" -- seriously, WTF? but I think there are people who think like this, about virginity being something to be got rid of on almost any not-actually-violent terms). The narrative presents this situation as her choice, but it somehow gave me the impression that it wasn't really, if that makes any sense.
ReplyDelete1: Bat Mitzvah's probably don't have any power due to the lack of influence religion has in our life and the fact that they happen at such a young age. (After my Bar Mitzvah, what changed? I stopped having to practice for my Bar Mitzvah)
ReplyDelete2: If anything, I think this story strengthens your authority as a sexblogger. It gives you perspective, and the fact that you can approach it so evenhandedly and with such nuance does you a great deal of credit. You're not just happy-go-lucky sex-is-fun, you can also approach the darker sides of personal issues without flinching.
For what little it's worth, I got a lot more capable of thinking of myself as an adult when I realised that "being an adult" was nigh-synonymous with "coming to terms with the fact that everyone else is faking it too".
ReplyDeleteI also go through bouts of not wanting to talk about elements of my past because of not wanting to be reduced to the poor little victim. So yeah. That thing.
OMG! I do not feel like an adult either. I feel like a runaway too. I do not know that I have made it away though... I can still hear her in my head. Not as strong. Not as poisonous but still there. Of course there is always Sting to drown her out "Voices inside my head. Echoes of things that you said." The echoes part is what helps... distant and fading.
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing! :)))
I think liking kinky sex is the same as liking vanilla sex - different things just feel good for different people. I am a submissive and have never had any sexual traumas and or emotional abuse.
ReplyDeleteI still understand the social stigma with trauma and liking kink - I believed the two were correlated until just recently. I didn't think someone could be into kinky sex unless they were somehow traumatized and when my submissive side started surfacing, I didn't understand why this felt good to me. I really thought that I might be repressing something. This just has to do with society trying to categorize us and tell us what is right and wrong, and if you don't it into their view than something must have made you this way.
Why can't you just enjoy what you want to enjoy? I happen to like mac and cheese and I happen to like getting slapped while having sex. I just like it. A lot. It upsets me that society has fucked us up so much that we have to suppress things about ourselves that feel good and don't harm anyone.
I'm still coming to terms with all of this stuff - I recently stumbled upon a feminist sub's blog and through her links, your blog, and they really speak to me in a way that nothing else has. It really captures the essence of what I feel. Thank you.
That was a very interesting and honest post. One thing I have found in regards to my past is that it doesnt totally define me but it no doubt has an affect on how I express myself in certain situations. At 47 Im still learning the good with the bad. Thanks for this post.
ReplyDelete"But I'm wary of the "damaged goods" pity-smear, of being reduced to my traumas, and sometimes it silences me. I don't want to make this blog into a narrative of "ex-child-prostitute/emotional abuse survivor/sexual assault survivor has promiscuous and painful sex!" Every part of that is technically true but it's not my story. It's ridiculous just how little it's my story."
ReplyDeleteThis. Yes. Hardcore.
I got linked to your blog from the article posted on skepchicks.org It's really great, and you motivated me to write a (nominal) response to this particular post at http://israelkwalker.wordpress.com/2012/02/13/the-poster-child-strikes-back/
ReplyDeleteIt's just so weird to read someone else feeling the same thing: looking at this past and this present and not wanting people to confuse the cause (being me) with part of the story (bad shit). Anyway, my wife and I read your "My Polyamorous Heart" post and its our new favorite way to explain poly to people. Thanks, and good blogging.
I know I'm late to this, but this struck such a chord with me because I was thinking today of how emotionally abusive my father was and how much I wanted to run away when I was in college. I never had the courage to, but then my father didn't treat me like your mother did you. Even then, I doubt I'd have had the courage. I did contemplate going to my best friend's house and asking her parents to take me in till I could get on my feet.
ReplyDeleteI'm so sorry you had to go through that.